If you are mid‑career or nearing retirement in the NHS, the McCloud judgement can feel like yet another complicated change you are expected to understand overnight. You may have received letters about “remedy periods” or “options exercises” without a clear explanation of what they mean in real life.
This guide is written for NHS staff in England and Wales—including nurses, healthcare assistants, allied health professionals, junior doctors, consultants and surgeons, as well as administrative and managerial staff. It explains, in plain English, how the McCloud judgement affects NHS pension scheme members, who is likely to benefit, and how it might influence your decisions about work and retirement. It is general information, not financial advice.
What is the McCloud judgement in simple terms?
The McCloud judgement arose from legal challenges about how certain public sector pension reforms were introduced. In short:
In 2015, many public sector pension schemes, including the NHS scheme, were reformed.
Older members were given transitional protection, meaning they could stay in their older, often more generous, schemes for longer.
Younger members were moved more quickly into the new 2015 schemes.
The courts decided that this difference in treatment, based purely on age, was unlawful discrimination. The government had to put in place a remedy to remove that discrimination and treat members fairly.
For NHS staff in England and Wales, this remedy is what people usually mean when they talk about “McCloud”. It does not create a brand‑new pension scheme, but it does give some members a choice about how part of their pension is treated.
Who will benefit from the McCloud judgement in the NHS?
The detail can be technical, but the broad idea is that McCloud mainly affects NHS staff who:
Were in service on or before 31 March 2012,
Were still in service on or after 1 April 2015,
Have pensionable service during the remedy period from 1 April 2015 to 31 March 2022.
If you fall into that group, the remedy aims to remove the disadvantage you faced compared with older staff who were allowed to stay longer in the old schemes.
In practice, the remedy usually works like this:
For the remedy period (2015–2022), you will be given a choice at retirement (or when you take benefits) about whether that period is treated as if you had been in your legacy scheme (for example, 1995 or 2008 section) or in the 2015 scheme.
This is sometimes called “deferred choice underpin” (DCU)—you make the choice later, when you can see which option gives you the better pension outcome.
Members who joined the NHS after the key dates, or who left before the remedy period, may not be directly affected. However, it is still worth checking your own position with the official scheme information.
If you have less than two years’ service in the NHS, you may still be building up pension entitlement, but you might fall outside the core McCloud remedy group depending on when you joined. If you are on sick leave or maternity leave, you will often still be treated as an active member of the scheme for pension purposes, but it is important to check the small print of your own circumstances and any breaks in service.
How McCloud interacts with the NHS pension schemes
Understanding McCloud is easier if you separate it into three layers:
Legacy schemes—for example, the 1995 and 2008 sections of the NHS Pension Scheme. These usually have different normal pension ages (often linked to 60 or 65) and different rules about final salary and accrual.
The 2015 scheme—a career‑average revalued earnings (CARE) scheme with a normal pension age linked to your State Pension age, and different accrual and revaluation rules.
The remedy period (1 April 2015 – 31 March 2022)—the window during which discrimination occurred.
Under the McCloud remedy in England and Wales:
All active members were moved into the 2015 scheme from 1 April 2022 onwards.
For the remedy period, eligible members will have a choice at the point they take benefits:
Treat the remedy‑period service as if it had been in their legacy scheme, or
Treat it as if it had been in the 2015 scheme.
The best choice will depend on factors such as how long you stay in NHS employment, your planned retirement age, how your pay changes over time, and whether you are taking ill‑health retirement, redundancy, flexible retirement or standard retirement.
Your scheme administrator should provide illustrations showing what each option would mean for you in cash terms.
What McCloud does not change
It is just as important to be clear about what McCloud does not do.
McCloud does not:
Give every member a large extra pension automatically.
Guarantee that staying in the older scheme is always better—for some people, the 2015 scheme benefits may in fact be higher.
Change the basic rules of the 2015 scheme from 1 April 2022 onwards—that is now the main scheme for almost all active NHS staff.
Turn general guidance into personalised financial advice—you still need to make decisions based on your own circumstances.
It also does not remove all the usual pension risks, such as:
How long you work in the NHS.
Whether you choose to work part‑time or take career breaks.
Future changes in tax, State Pension rules or broader government policy.
Managing expectations is important. For some members, the McCloud remedy will make a noticeable difference. For others, the effect may be modest.
How McCloud might affect your retirement planning
Because McCloud changes how part of your pension is calculated, it can influence decisions such as when to retire, whether to go part‑time, or how to respond to a redundancy or ill‑health situation.
Some examples of questions people in England and Wales are asking:
If I retire at 60 instead of my State Pension age, does choosing to treat the remedy period as legacy‑scheme service make more sense?
If I plan to work well beyond State Pension age, could the 2015 scheme benefits for the remedy period be better in the long run?
How does McCloud interact with redundancy pay, flexible retirement or ill‑health retirement options that my Trust is discussing with me?
Practical steps:
Wait for, or request, your official pension illustrations that show both remedy options side by side.
List the other moving pieces (for example, mortgage, dependants, health, other savings) before jumping to conclusions based only on headline pension numbers.
Remember that decisions about leaving dates, reducing hours or taking lump sums can have knock‑on effects well beyond the McCloud remedy itself.
Because these choices are complex and long‑term, many people will benefit from talking to a regulated financial adviser who understands public sector and NHS pensions.
Where to get personalised advice and official information
You do not have to work everything out alone. Good sources of information for NHS staff in England and Wales include:
Official NHS Pension Scheme communications—website guidance, member booklets, remedy FAQs and personalised letters.
Scheme administrators—they can explain how your benefits are calculated and what information your statements show, although they cannot give regulated financial advice.
Regulated financial advisers—especially those with experience of NHS pensions and public sector schemes.
Unions and professional bodies—many provide guidance, factsheets and webinars on McCloud and pension changes.
Be cautious about:
Anyone promising guaranteed outcomes or unusually high returns.
Relying solely on informal social media advice without checking it against official sources.
Using Caira to understand pension letters and options packs
Pension letters and options packs are often written in dense, technical language. It is easy to miss key points when you are tired or anxious about money.
Caira is an AI‑powered, privacy‑first legal assistant built for people dealing with legal and procedural questions in England and Wales. While it cannot give regulated financial advice, it can help you:
Upload pension statements, McCloud remedy letters, options forms, redundancy or retirement packs and related emails as PDFs, Word documents, spreadsheets, photos or screenshots.
Ask questions in plain English such as “What is this letter telling me about my remedy‑period service?” or “What is the difference between these two options?” and get clear explanations in seconds.
Generate draft questions to ask your financial adviser, union or scheme administrator, as well as draft emails or notes, so you can make the most of any appointment.
Ask Caira to compare two versions of a statement or options pack and highlight what has changed, so you are less likely to miss important differences.
Behind the scenes, Caira reads both your uploaded documents and a large internal library of more than 10,000 legal and tax documents for England and Wales, then uses generative AI to give tailored explanations.
From a privacy point of view:
Caira is designed to be privacy‑first—your data is not used to train public AI models.
Your documents are not passed to third‑party human reviewers.
You can try Caira with a 14‑day free trial that takes under a minute to start and does not require a credit card. After that it is an affordable, low‑cost subscription—roughly the cost of a cheap takeaway each month—at £15/month, available 24/7 on your phone, tablet or laptop.
Used well, Caira will not replace regulated financial advice, but it can help you feel more prepared and less overwhelmed before you speak to a professional.
No credit card required
