If you’re reading this, you may be feeling let down by the very system meant to protect you and your child. Many parents in England and Wales find themselves questioning whether what happened during childbirth was simply “bad luck” or something more serious—medical negligence. Understanding the difference is the first step towards getting answers and, if appropriate, seeking justice.
Defining Medical Negligence in Maternity Care
Medical negligence isn’t just about something going wrong. It’s about a breach of duty—a situation where the care you received fell below the standard expected of a reasonably competent healthcare professional, and that failure caused harm. The legal test most often used is known as the Bolam test. In simple terms, it asks: Did the clinician act in a way that no other reasonably competent professional would have done in the same circumstances?
This is not about perfection. Medicine is complex, and not every poor outcome is the result of negligence. But when basic standards are missed, and harm results, the law may be on your side.
What Typically Qualifies as Negligence in Childbirth?
Certain failures in maternity care are repeatedly seen in successful claims. These include:
Failure to Monitor: If staff did not properly monitor your baby’s heart rate during labour, and distress went unnoticed, this can lead to oxygen deprivation and brain injury. Failing to act on abnormal readings is a common theme.
Delayed Caesarean Section: Sometimes, a caesarean is needed urgently. Unnecessary delays—whether due to indecision, lack of staff, or poor communication—can result in serious harm to mother or baby.
Instrument Misuse: Forceps and vacuum extractors (ventouse) are sometimes needed, but incorrect use can cause skull fractures, brain damage, or severe tears.
Misdiagnosis and Delayed Treatment: Missing signs of conditions like pre-eclampsia, infection, or failing to respond to abnormal symptoms can be grounds for a claim.
Perineal Tears and Surgical Errors: Not diagnosing or treating severe tears, or errors during episiotomy or caesarean, can lead to lasting injury.
On the other hand, not every complication or poor outcome is negligence. If staff acted reasonably, followed guidelines, and complications arose despite their best efforts, the law may not support a claim. It’s important to be honest with yourself about what happened, and to focus on clear failures rather than general dissatisfaction.
How to Review Your Experience Against the Legal Threshold
Start by writing down everything you remember. Don’t worry about getting it perfect—just get it out. Think about:
What happened before, during, and after labour?
Were you or your baby monitored regularly? Did anyone explain what was happening?
Did you feel ignored, dismissed, or pressured into decisions?
Were there delays in treatment or unexplained changes in your care?
Did you experience injuries that weren’t properly treated or explained?
Next, compare your experience to what you now know about common negligence themes. Did staff fail to act on warning signs? Was there a delay that had serious consequences? Did you suffer an injury that could have been avoided with proper care?
If you’re unsure, try to separate your feelings from the facts. It’s natural to feel angry or betrayed, but the law focuses on what can be proven. If you can point to specific failures—missed monitoring, ignored symptoms, delayed interventions—you may have the basis for a claim.
Common Misconceptions and Emotional Impact
Many parents believe that any bad outcome must be someone’s fault. Sadly, that’s not always true. The law is strict, and many cases don’t succeed because the evidence isn’t strong enough, or because the harm couldn’t have been prevented even with perfect care.
Another misconception is that the hospital or PALS (Patient Advice and Liaison Service) will help you get justice. In reality, PALS is there to resolve complaints and support communication, not to admit fault or help you build a legal case. Many parents find their concerns dismissed or minimised, which can be deeply frustrating.
The emotional toll is real. You may feel isolated, unheard, or overwhelmed by medical jargon and bureaucracy. It’s important to acknowledge these feelings, but also to focus on what you can control—gathering evidence and telling your story clearly.
Why Some Cases Don’t Succeed
Even when you’re sure something went wrong, claims can fail for several reasons:
Lack of clear evidence linking the failure to the harm suffered.
Staff acted within accepted guidelines, even if the outcome was poor.
Records are missing, incomplete, or contradict your account.
The harm was unavoidable, even with perfect care.
This is why documenting your experience is so important. The more detail you can provide, the stronger your case will be.
Action: How to Start Documenting Your Experience
If you don’t trust hospital staff or PALS, you’re not alone. Many parents feel the system is stacked against them. But you can take steps to protect yourself and your child’s interests:
Write a Detailed Account: Start with your own words. What happened, when, who was involved, what was said, and how you felt. Include dates, times, and names if possible.
Request Your Medical Records: You have a right to see your notes, CTG traces, and any correspondence. Put your request in writing, and keep copies of everything.
Keep a Diary: Record ongoing symptoms, emotional impact, and any interactions with staff or PALS. This can be powerful evidence.
Gather Witness Statements: If your partner, family, or friends were present, ask them to write down what they saw and heard.
Save All Correspondence: Letters, emails, and even text messages can help build your case.
If PALS dismisses your concerns, don’t give up. You can escalate your complaint to the hospital’s formal complaints process, and ultimately to NHS Resolution or the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman. Persistence is key.
Final Thoughts
Medical negligence in childbirth is a deeply personal and often traumatic experience. The legal process can feel cold and unhelpful, especially if you’re self-representing and don’t trust the system. But by understanding what counts as negligence, reviewing your experience honestly, and documenting everything, you give yourself the best chance of being heard.
Feel less anxious and more confident:
Caira is your new bestie!👱🏼♀️🌸 Get answers and drafts in seconds for public, family, probate, conveyancing, criminal, employment, medical negligence, commercial and public law. All backed by 10,000 legal documents for England and Wales.
Upload documents, screenshots and photos for even more relevant responses. Free 14 days trial in 1 min – no credit card required, afterwards just £15/month on our website. Continue chatting now. https://www.unwildered.co.uk
Disclaimer: This blog post provides general information for educational purposes only. It is not legal advice. Outcomes can vary based on your personal circumstances.